12 Secret Santa Gifts for a Baseball Player

Last updated: October 4, 2023

#1 Two Toned MLB Logo Coffee Mug

Boelter Brands Two Toned Matte Black Coffee Mug, MLB Team Logo with Inner Team Color (New York Yankees)

This Boelter Brands Matte Black Coffee Mug is great for baseball enthusiasts, particularly Yankees fans. It subtly features the team logo on a matte black finish, and has an inner team color detail. The mug is microwave and dishwasher safe, full-sized, and 100% ceramic, adding practicality to its attractive design.

#2 Baseball/Softball Score Keeping Book, 25 Games

Franklin Sports Baseball + Softball Scorebook - Score Keeping Book for Stats Coaching Official Scorekeeper 25 Game

The Franklin Sports Baseball + Softball Scorebook is a thoughtful gift for baseball enthusiasts. It simplifies the tracking of stats and scores for 25 games, and accommodates up to 16 players in a lineup. It also includes a roster page for keeping players' contact info. It's an all-in-one solution to make game tracking fun and easy.

#3 Personalized Atlanta Baseball History Book

Signature gifts Personalized Atlanta Baseball History Book - Sports Fan Gift - A Major League History Told Through Archive Newspaper Coverage (Atlanta Braves)

The "Signature gifts Personalized Atlanta Baseball History Book" is a richly detailed and beautifully presented gem for any Atlanta Braves or baseball enthusiast. Boasting over 100 years of Braves history, this personalized keepsake is bound in a sophisticated tan leatherette cover and would make a thoughtful Secret Santa gift.

#4 Baseball Themed T-Shirt

Eat Sleep Baseball Repeat - Baseball Lover Themed T-Shirt

As a reviewer, "Eat Sleep Baseball Repeat - Baseball Lover Themed T-Shirt" makes a fitting Secret Santa gift for baseball enthusiasts. With its lightweight, classic fit, and durable double-needle sleeve and bottom hem, it pairs comfort with a shared love for the game - a casual, versatile nod to their favorite sport.

#5 Leather Baseball Keychain for Car Bag

Towashine Baseball Seamed Leather Key Chain for Car Bag Purse Accessories Gifts(White)

The Towashine Baseball Seamed Leather Key Chain would delight any baseball enthusiast. Crafted from leather, it boasts realistic baseball stitching, serving both as a stylish accessory for car keys, bags, or purses, and a nod to their love for baseball. Its convenient size makes it a thoughtful, useable gift.

#6 Adult Baseball Glove with Adjustable Wrist Strap

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Baseball/Softball Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch

The Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove would be a thoughtful Secret Santa gift for a baseball enthusiast. Its basket web design and 12.5-inch size make it versatile for any field position, while the full grain leather and zero-shock palm padding ensure durability and comfort. Additionally, it needs minimal break-in, a cherry on top!

#7 "UV Protected Acrylic Baseball Display Case"

Laypia Baseball Display Case 2 Pack - Acrylic UV Protected Baseball Case, Autographed Baseball Holder for Display, Clear Fadeproof Baseball Cube Box, for Official Size Ball

The Laypia Baseball Display Case is perfect for baseball enthusiasts, providing a secure, visually appealing place for their precious collectibles. Made from high-quality acrylic board, this UV-protected case effectively shields baseballs from external factors, while its transparent design offers easy viewing. The stackable feature is also advantageous for displaying multiple balls. This makes it an ideal Secret Santa gift for any baseball collector.

#8 Customized Mini Baseball Bat Gift

Personalized Mini Bat 18″, Custom Mini Baseball Bat, Fathers Day, Personalized Coach Gift, Team Gift, Tee Ball, Baseball Team Coach Gift, Little League Gift, Softball Team Coach Gift, Coaches Gift

The Personalized Mini Bat 18” is an ideal Secret Santa gift for anyone who loves baseball. It's made from high-quality Maple wood, engraved with precision by a professional company. This 18-inch mini bat can be personalized, making it a unique keepsake for a coach, father or team player.

#9 MLB Team Logos 500pc Shaped Puzzle

MasterPieces MLB1010: MLB Team Logos 500pc Homeplate Shaped Puzzle

The MasterPieces MLB1010 is a great Secret Santa gift for baseball enthusiasts. This 500-piece puzzle forms a 25 x 22 inch home plate displaying all MLB team logos. It comes with 5 special die-shaped pieces and promises quality with its thick, interlocking pieces. A perfect tribute to a baseball fan's dedication!

#10 MLB Baseball Trivia Board Game

MasterPieces MLB3000: MLB Baseball Trivia Game

The MasterPieces MLB3000 offers a fantastic blend of baseball trivia and interactive board game play. With 1000 unique MLB questions and an officially licensed product, it's an ideal pick for baseball enthusiasts to test their knowledge. Complete with all necessary cards and rules, it's a worthwhile gift for any Secret Santa exchange.

#11 Sport Equipment Organizer with Front Pockets

mDesign Sports Equipment Organizer Bin with Front Pockets - Basketball, Hockey Stick, Football, Baseball Bat, Frisbee, and Ball Organizer for Garage - Storage Rack for Sports Gear - Black

The mDesign Sports Equipment Organizer Bin is a handy storage solution for any baseball enthusiast. Its durable wire frame and polyester bag hold bats, balls, and gear in two large baskets or six front pockets. The adjustable feet adapt to uneven surfaces, making it versatile for any room. An added bonus is the optional grid for upright storage, ensuring easy access to equipment.

#12 Decorative Baseball Glove Wine Bottle Holder

EXCELLO GLOBAL PRODUCTS Wine Bottle Holder: Unique Decorative Baseball Glove Design for Tabletop Display in Home, Kitchen, or Bar

The Excello Global Products Wine Bottle Holder is an ideal Secret Santa gift for baseball enthusiasts. It's handcrafted to resemble a vintage baseball glove, offering a unique detail to home decor. Compact and durable, it fits in small spaces and is built to last. A charming and practical addition to any baseball lover's collection.